Problem 1
There are integers greater than written on a blackboard, not necessarily different. In a move, Confucius chooses two integers and from different places on the blackboard and replaces these two integers with and . He continues to make moves while it is possible to do so. (a) Prove that, regardless of the choices of Confucius, after finitely many moves, exactly one integer on the blackboard is greater than . (b) Prove that the value of does not depend on the choices of Confucius.
Step 1 of 4: Rewrite the replacement and track the product
Detailed analysis
Using , the two replacement numbers are and , whose product is . Whenever , this new product is strictly smaller than the old pair product , so the product of all numbers on the blackboard strictly decreases; whenever , the replacement is , which leaves the total product unchanged but creates a new (since had neither equal to , while ).