Problem 5
Let be a real-valued function defined for all real numbers such that, for some positive constant , the equation holds for all . (a) Prove that is periodic. (b) For , give an example of a non-constant function with the required property.
Step 4 of 5: Define a non-constant example for a = 1
In plain words
The construction is a two-state clock: on one unit interval the value is , on the next it is , and the pattern repeats. The recurrence maps to and to , so shifting by one interval performs exactly the required state swap.
Detailed analysis
For , define when and when , for an integer . These half-open intervals partition the real line, so the definition is unambiguous and is non-constant. It is also visibly periodic with period .