Problem 1
Let be the set of integers. Determine all functions such that, for all integers and ,
Step 3 of 7: Derive additivity
In plain words
Substituting the doubling identity into another pair of instances of P cancels the outer f and leaves a plain additive relation.
Detailed analysis
Comparing P(a, b) and P(0, a+b), both equal f(f(a+b)): the first gives f(2a) + 2f(b), and the second gives f(0) + 2f(a+b). Replacing f(2a) using the identity from the previous step and simplifying shows that f(a) + f(b) minus f(0) equals f(a+b), for all integers a and b.