MathLabs

Problem 6

Let ABCABC be an equilateral triangle. Let A1,B1,C1A_1,B_1,C_1 be interior points of ABCABC such that BA1=A1CBA_1=A_1C, CB1=B1ACB_1=B_1A, AC1=C1BAC_1=C_1B, and ∠BA1C+∠CB1A+∠AC1B=480∘\angle BA_1C+\angle CB_1A+\angle AC_1B=480^\circ. Let A2=BC1∩CB1A_2=BC_1\cap CB_1, B2=CA1∩AC1B_2=CA_1\cap AC_1, C2=AB1∩BA1C_2=AB_1\cap BA_1. Prove that if triangle A1B1C1A_1B_1C_1 is scalene, then the circumcircles of triangles AA1A2AA_1A_2, BB1B2BB_1B_2, and CC1C2CC_1C_2 all pass through two common points.
Step 3 of 6: Three auxiliary circles and a non-cyclic hexagon
In plain words

Since C2 and B2 lie on the very rays A1B and A1C, the hexagon's angle at A1 is literally the same angle as the given angle BA1C, and a directed-angle chase elsewhere shows four carefully chosen points around each vertex are concyclic.

∠C2A1B2=∠BA1C, ∠A2B1C2=∠CB1A, ∠B2C1A2=∠AC1B\angle C_2A_1B_2=\angle BA_1C,\ \angle A_2B_1C_2=\angle CB_1A,\ \angle B_2C_1A_2=\angle AC_1B
Detailed analysis

Use directed angles modulo 180∘180^\circ. The circumcenter result in Step 2 gives B1A=B1C=B1B2B_1A=B_1C=B_1B_2 and C1A=C1B=C1C2C_1A=C_1B=C_1C_2. Hence A,C,B2A,C,B_2 lie on the circle centered at B1B_1, while A,B,C2A,B,C_2 lie on the circle centered at C1C_1. Since C2C_2 lies on AB1AB_1 and B2B_2 lies on AC1AC_1, we calculate ∡B2B1C2=180∘−∡AB1B2=180∘−2∡ACB2=180∘−2(60∘−α)=60∘+2α\measuredangle B_2B_1C_2=180^\circ-\measuredangle AB_1B_2=180^\circ-2\measuredangle ACB_2=180^\circ-2(60^\circ-\alpha)=60^\circ+2\alpha. Similarly, ∡B2C1C2=180∘−∡AC1C2=180∘−2∡ABC2=180∘−2(60∘−α)=60∘+2α\measuredangle B_2C_1C_2=180^\circ-\measuredangle AC_1C_2=180^\circ-2\measuredangle ABC_2=180^\circ-2(60^\circ-\alpha)=60^\circ+2\alpha. Thus B2,C1,B1,C2B_2,C_1,B_1,C_2 are concyclic; call their circle ωa\omega_a. Cyclically define ωb=(C2A1C1A2)\omega_b=(C_2A_1C_1A_2) and ωc=(A2B1A1B2)\omega_c=(A_2B_1A_1B_2). The same angle computations prove these incidences, not merely by a picture. Finally, A2,C1,B2,A1,C2,B1A_2,C_1,B_2,A_1,C_2,B_1 occur in this order on a strictly convex hexagon: each AiA_i lies beyond the two adjacent points on the corresponding cevians because 0<α,β,γ<30∘0<\alpha,\beta,\gamma<30^\circ. If the three auxiliary circles were not pairwise distinct, all six vertices would be concyclic; but a convex cyclic hexagon would satisfy 360∘=∠C2A1B2+∠B2C1A2+∠A2B1C2=∠BA1C+∠CB1A+∠AC1B=480∘360^\circ=\angle C_2A_1B_2+\angle B_2C_1A_2+\angle A_2B_1C_2=\angle BA_1C+\angle CB_1A+\angle AC_1B=480^\circ, impossible. Hence they are pairwise distinct.