MathLabs

Problem 4

Shan-Yu and Mulan are playing a game. Let θ\theta be an angle with 0∘<θ<180∘0^\circ<\theta<180^\circ known to both players. Initially, Shan-Yu makes a paper triangle TT with measurements of his choice. Then, they repeatedly perform the following steps: if TT has at least one angle measuring exactly θ\theta, then the game stops and Mulan wins; otherwise, Mulan chooses a point PP on the perimeter of TT, different from its three vertices, and makes a straight cut from PP to the opposite vertex of TT, splitting it into two triangles; Shan-Yu discards one of the two triangles, and the remaining triangle becomes the new TT. For which real values of θ\theta can Mulan guarantee her victory in finitely many steps, no matter how Shan-Yu plays?
Step 2 of 4: Mulan wins whenever θ = 180°/n
θ=180∘n (n≥2):∠A=90∘, ∠B≤45∘, 45∘<kθ≤90∘ ⟹ ∠ADC=kθ, ∠ADB=(n−k)θ\theta=\frac{180^\circ}{n}\ (n\ge2):\quad \angle A=90^\circ,\ \angle B\le45^\circ,\ 45^\circ<k\theta\le90^\circ\ \Longrightarrow\ \angle ADC=k\theta,\ \angle ADB=(n-k)\theta
Detailed analysis

Assume θ=180∘/n\theta=180^\circ/n for an integer n≥2n\ge2. Let the largest angle of the initial triangle be at VV; its altitude to the opposite side meets that side in its interior (the other two angles are acute), so this is a legal first cut. Either retained piece is a right triangle. Relabel the retained triangle as ABCABC with ∠A=90∘\angle A=90^\circ and, after interchanging B,CB,C, ∠B≤45∘\angle B\le45^\circ. If n=2n=2, then θ=90∘=∠A\theta=90^\circ=\angle A and Mulan wins immediately. For n≥3n\ge3, choose an integer kk with n/4<k≤n/2n/4<k\le n/2: for n=3n=3 use k=1k=1, while for n≥4n\ge4 the half-open interval (n/4,n/2](n/4,n/2] contains an integer because its length is at least one. Hence 45∘<kθ≤90∘45^\circ<k\theta\le90^\circ. Since ∠B≤45∘\angle B\le45^\circ, the number kθ−∠Bk\theta-\angle B is strictly between 0∘0^\circ and 90∘90^\circ; therefore the ray from AA making this angle with ABAB meets the interior of BCBC at a legal point DD. In △ABD\triangle ABD, the exterior-angle theorem gives ∠ADC=∠B+∠BAD=kθ\angle ADC=\angle B+\angle BAD=k\theta. The adjacent angle is ∠ADB=180∘−kθ=(n−k)θ\angle ADB=180^\circ-k\theta=(n-k)\theta, and n−k≥1n-k\ge1. Thus one child, ABDABD, contains the positive integer multiple (n−k)θ(n-k)\theta, while the other, ACDACD, contains kθk\theta; step 1 wins from whichever child Shan-Yu retains, after only these two cuts.