MathLabs

Open problem, Arithmetic and number theory, posed 1900

Hilbert's twelfth problem

OpenHilbert #12

For an arbitrary algebraic number field KK, find analytic functions whose special values generate the maximal abelian extension KabK^{\mathrm{ab}} of KK — generalizing the Kronecker–Weber theorem, where the exponential values exp⁡(2πi/n)\exp(2\pi i/n) generate Qab\mathbb{Q}^{\mathrm{ab}}, and Kronecker's Jugendtraum ('dearest dream of youth'), where special values of elliptic and modular functions generate KabK^{\mathrm{ab}} for imaginary quadratic fields K=Q(−d)K = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-d}).

Research frontier as of 2026

As of 2026 Hilbert's twelfth problem is solved in several major regimes — over Q\mathbb{Q} (Kronecker–Weber), over imaginary quadratic fields (classical complex multiplication), over global function fields (Drinfeld, 1974), and, in a pp-adic analytic formulation, over every totally real number field (Dasgupta–Kakde, 2021–2023) — while remaining open in its original complex-analytic form and for general number fields with both real and complex embeddings. Dasgupta and Kakde proved the Brumer–Stark conjecture and the integral Gross–Stark conjecture for totally real fields FF using Ribet's method on group-ring-valued Hilbert modular Eisenstein series and Ritter–Weiss modules, showing that Brumer–Stark pp-units constructed from pp-adic multiplicative integrals (together with [F:Q]−1[F:\mathbb{Q}]-1 square roots) generate FabF^{\mathrm{ab}}. Parallel work by Henri Darmon, Samit Dasgupta, Jan Vonk, and collaborators on rigid meromorphic cocycles on the pp-adic upper half-plane provides a striking pp-adic analogue of the modular jj-invariant for real quadratic fields. A purely archimedean (complex-analytic) generator for real quadratic or mixed-signature number fields, or an unconditional proof of the archimedean Stark conjectures, remains out of reach.

Best known results

  • Complete classical solutions for Q\mathbb{Q} via cyclotomic values exp⁡(2πi/n)\exp(2\pi i/n) (Kronecker–Weber, 1886) and for imaginary quadratic fields via elliptic and modular functions with complex multiplication (Kronecker, Weber, Takagi, Shimura).
  • Complete solution for global function fields via torsion points of Drinfeld modules (Drinfeld, 1974).
  • Proof of the Brumer–Stark conjecture and explicit pp-adic analytic generation of FabF^{\mathrm{ab}} for every totally real number field FF via Gross–Stark units (Dasgupta–Kakde, 2021–2023, arXiv:2103.02516 and arXiv:2204.09037).

Tools and where they stop

ToolAchievedWhere it stops
Complex multiplication of elliptic curves and abelian varietiesGenerates the full maximal abelian extension of any imaginary quadratic field, and large abelian extensions of higher-dimensional CM fields, via special values of modular functions and torsion points.Abelian varieties over C\mathbb{C} cannot have real multiplication as their full endomorphism ring in the way needed to handle totally real fields, and even for higher-dimensional CM fields Shimura's theory does not generate the entire KabK^{\mathrm{ab}}.
Ribet's method and pp-adic Gross–Stark units (Dasgupta–Kakde)Uses congruences between Hilbert modular Eisenstein series and cusp forms to prove the Brumer–Stark and integral Gross–Stark conjectures, yielding explicit pp-adic analytic formulas for generators of FabF^{\mathrm{ab}} for any totally real field FF.Replaces complex analytic functions on archimedean symmetric spaces by pp-adic integration across auxiliary primes pp, and relies on the existence of a totally real base field admitting CM extensions.

Open questions

  • Can the archimedean rank-1 Stark conjecture be proved unconditionally, giving complex-analytic (rather than pp-adic) generators for the maximal abelian extensions of real quadratic and totally real fields?
  • How can explicit class field theory — whether pp-adic via rigid cocycles or archimedean via Stark units — be extended to number fields with mixed signature (having both real and complex places)?

References

  1. David Hilbert (1900). Mathematische Probleme
  2. Vladimir G. Drinfeld (1974). Elliptic modules · DOI:10.1007/978-1-4614-5888-3_2
  3. Samit Dasgupta, Mahesh Kakde (2023). On the Brumer–Stark conjecture · arXiv:2204.09037
  4. Samit Dasgupta, Mahesh Kakde (2021). Brumer–Stark units and explicit class field theory · arXiv:2103.02516 [preprint, not peer-reviewed]