MathLabs

Open problem, Arithmetic and number theory, Algebra, posed 1933

Lehmer's Mahler measure problem

Open

Does there exist a constant μ>1\mu > 1 such that every integer polynomial P(x)∈Z[x]P(x) \in \mathbb{Z}[x] with Mahler measure M(P)>1M(P) > 1 satisfies M(P)≥μM(P) \ge \mu? More specifically, is Lehmer's number λ≈1.17628\lambda \approx 1.17628, the Mahler measure of L(x)=x10+x9−x7−x6−x5−x4−x3+x+1L(x) = x^{10} + x^9 - x^7 - x^6 - x^5 - x^4 - x^3 + x + 1, the smallest Mahler measure strictly greater than 11?

Research frontier as of 2026

As of 2026, Lehmer's Mahler measure problem remains open. Smyth's 1971 theorem completely resolves the non-reciprocal case by establishing the sharp lower bound θ0≈1.32471\theta_0 \approx 1.32471, so any counterexample must be a reciprocal polynomial of even degree. Dobrowolski's 1979 inequality and its subsequent refinements rule out Mahler measures approaching 11 too rapidly as the degree dd grows, and Dimitrov (2019) proved the Schinzel–Zassenhaus conjecture on the maximum modulus of conjugates, a long-standing sibling problem. Nevertheless, no method has eliminated the possibility of high-degree reciprocal polynomials (or Salem numbers) with Mahler measure strictly between 11 and λ≈1.17628\lambda \approx 1.17628.

Best known results

  • Smyth (1971): every non-reciprocal integer polynomial P(x)P(x) with P(0)≠0P(0) \ne 0 satisfies M(P)≥θ0≈1.32471795M(P) \ge \theta_0 \approx 1.32471795.
  • Dobrowolski (1979): for any non-cyclotomic irreducible integer polynomial of degree dd, M(P)>1+c(log⁡log⁡d/log⁡d)3M(P) > 1 + c (\log \log d / \log d)^3.
  • Exhaustive computation (Mossinghoff, Rhin, and Wu 2008) verifies that λ≈1.1762808\lambda \approx 1.1762808 is the minimum Mahler measure >1> 1 for all degrees d≤44d \le 44.

Tools and where they stop

ToolAchievedWhere it stops
Auxiliary polynomials and resultant bounds (Dobrowolski's method)Gives the best general asymptotic lower bound M(P)>1+c(log⁡log⁡d/log⁡d)3M(P) > 1 + c (\log \log d / \log d)^3 in terms of the degree ddThe factor (log⁡log⁡d/log⁡d)3(\log \log d / \log d)^3 decays to 00 as d→∞d \to \infty, failing to yield a degree-independent constant μ>1\mu > 1
Holomorphic / Hankel determinant techniques (Dimitrov's method)Resolves the Schinzel–Zassenhaus conjecture on the largest conjugate modulus (house) of algebraic integersRequires non-reciprocal structure or power series non-rationality that breaks down when conjugates cluster near the unit circle in reciprocal polynomials

Open questions

  • Is there a universal constant μ>1\mu > 1 bounding M(P)M(P) away from 11 across all degrees dd?
  • Is Lehmer's number λ≈1.17628\lambda \approx 1.17628 the smallest Salem number?

References

  1. D. H. Lehmer (1933). Factorization of certain cyclotomic functions · DOI:10.2307/1968172
  2. C. J. Smyth (1971). On the product of the conjugates outside the unit circle of an algebraic integer · DOI:10.1112/blms/3.2.169
  3. E. Dobrowolski (1979). On a question of Lehmer and the number of irreducible factors of a polynomial · DOI:10.4064/aa-34-4-391-401
  4. Enrico Bombieri, Walter Gubler (2006). Heights in Diophantine Geometry · DOI:10.1017/CBO9780511542879