MathLabs
TheoremProved

The boundary operator squares to zero

Statement

For the simplicial boundary map, ∂n∘∂n+1=0\partial_n \circ \partial_{n+1} = 0 for every nn.

Why is it true?

This single identity is what makes homology well-defined: it guarantees im⁡∂n+1⊆ker⁡∂n\operatorname{im} \partial_{n+1} \subseteq \ker \partial_n, so the quotient in the definition of Hn(X)H_n(X) actually makes sense as a group.

Proof sketch

It suffices to check the claim on a single nn-simplex σ=[v0,…,vn]\sigma = [v_0, \dots, v_n] and extend by linearity. By definition, ∂nσ=∑i=0n(−1)i[v0,…,vi^,…,vn]\partial_n \sigma = \sum_{i=0}^n (-1)^i [v_0, \dots, \hat{v_i}, \dots, v_n], where vi^\hat{v_i} means viv_i is deleted.

Applying ∂n−1\partial_{n-1} to each term and deleting a second vertex vjv_j (with j≠ij \ne i) from [v0,…,vi^,…,vn][v_0, \dots, \hat{v_i}, \dots, v_n] produces the face [v0,…,vj^,…,vi^,…,vn][v_0, \dots, \hat{v_j}, \dots, \hat{v_i}, \dots, v_n] that is missing exactly the two vertices vi,vjv_i, v_j. Carefully tracking the sign: when j<ij < i the face is deleted at position jj first (sign (−1)j(-1)^j) inside a term already carrying sign (−1)i(-1)^i, giving total sign (−1)i+j(-1)^{i+j}; when j>ij > i, deleting vjv_j from the (n−1)(n-1)-simplex [v0,…,vi^,…,vn][v_0,\dots,\hat{v_i},\dots,v_n] removes the vertex now sitting at position j−1j-1 (because viv_i was already removed), giving sign (−1)i(−1)j−1=−(−1)i+j(-1)^i (-1)^{j-1} = -(-1)^{i+j}.

So ∂n−1∂nσ=∑j<i(−1)i+j[…,vj^,…,vi^,… ]+∑j>i(−(−1)i+j)[…,vi^,…,vj^,… ]\partial_{n-1}\partial_n \sigma = \sum_{j<i} (-1)^{i+j} [\dots,\hat{v_j},\dots,\hat{v_i},\dots] + \sum_{j>i} \left(-(-1)^{i+j}\right) [\dots,\hat{v_i},\dots,\hat{v_j},\dots]. Every face missing exactly two vertices {vi,vj}\{v_i, v_j\} with i<ji < j appears exactly twice in this double sum: once from deleting viv_i then vjv_j (contributing −(−1)i+j-(-1)^{i+j}) and once from deleting vjv_j then viv_i (contributing +(−1)i+j+(-1)^{i+j}), and these two contributions are exact opposites.

Every term cancels in pairs, so ∂n−1∂nσ=0\partial_{n-1}\partial_n \sigma = 0 for every simplex σ\sigma, hence ∂n∘∂n+1=0\partial_n \circ \partial_{n+1} = 0 on all of CnC_n by linearity.

Topics that use this theorem

Step-by-step proofs

No step-by-step proof yet for this theorem.

References

  1. Allen Hatcher (2002). Algebraic Topology
  2. James R. Munkres (1984). Elements of Algebraic Topology
  3. Gunnar Carlsson (2009). Topology and data