The double-counting proof of a binomial identity
Statement
For every integer , .
Why is it true?
Both sides count the same thing — the number of ways to pick people out of — so no algebraic manipulation of binomial coefficients is needed at all, only a careful description of one selection process in two different orders.
Proof sketch
Consider a set of people consisting of boys and girls. We count, in two ways, the number of ways to choose a committee of exactly people from this set of .
Directly, by definition, this number is , since we are simply choosing objects out of .
Alternatively, split every valid committee according to how many boys it contains. If the committee contains exactly boys for some with , then those boys can be chosen in ways, and the remaining committee members must be girls, chosen from the girls in ways. By the symmetry identity , the number of committees with exactly boys is .
Every valid committee of people has some well-defined number of boys between and , and no committee is counted twice across different values of , so summing over all gives the total number of committees as .
Since both expressions count exactly the same set of committees, they must be equal: .
Topics that use this theorem
Step-by-step proofs
No step-by-step proof yet for this theorem.
References
- Noga Alon (1999). Combinatorial Nullstellensatz
- Béla Bollobás (1998). Modern Graph Theory
- Titu Andreescu, Zuming Feng (2003). 102 Combinatorial Problems