Problem 4
Given a plane , a point in and a point not in , find all points in such that the ratio is a maximum.
Step 2 of 5: Reduce to the ray PX when P≠X
Detailed analysis
Fix PR. On the circle in π centered at P, the numerator is fixed, while QR is smallest when R lies on the line PX on the same side of P as X. Thus every maximizer lies on the ray PX.