Worked solution: Tao's proof of the Erdős discrepancy problem via logarithmically averaged correlations (2015)
Imagine an infinite sequence of and coin-flip results, written down once and for all. You are allowed to pick any "skip" length and then add up the first results you get by looking only at positions — like reading every -th entry in a long list. Erdős asked in the 1930s whether it is possible to write down the sequence so cleverly that no matter which skip you choose and how far you look, this running total never grows beyond some fixed ceiling .
The surprising answer, found by Terence Tao in 2015, is no: however cleverly the sequence is chosen, some choice of skip and length will always eventually blow the total past any ceiling you name.
For a function , define its discrepancy as , the largest possible absolute value of a partial sum of restricted to a homogeneous arithmetic progression . Paul Erdős conjectured in the 1930s that this discrepancy is always infinite, i.e. for every and every constant , some make .
The problem resisted proof for over 80 years and became the subject of the 2010 Polymath5 collaborative project (initiated by Timothy Gowers), which established several partial results and equivalent reformulations but not the full conjecture. Terence Tao proved the full result in 2015 (published in Discrete Analysis, 2016), and in fact for the more general vector-valued statement where takes values in the unit sphere of any real or complex Hilbert space, not just .
The rest of this proof follows Tao's three-part strategy stated in his paper's abstract: a Fourier-analytic reduction (from the Polymath5 project) to completely multiplicative functions, a logarithmically averaged form of the Elliott conjecture on correlations (Tao's own separate 2015 result), and a final argument (extending an idea also from Polymath5) that rules out the one remaining case.
- Homogeneous arithmetic progression
- A list of multiples of a fixed number : ; "homogeneous" here means the progression starts at itself rather than at an arbitrary offset.