Math Labs

Worked solution: Abel–Ruffini theorem and the Galois solvability criterion (1824)

Step 1 of 8: Radical towers formalize 'solvable by radicals'
In plain words

A radical formula, like the quadratic formula x=(−b±b2−4ac)/2ax=(-b\pm\sqrt{b^2-4ac})/2a, is really just a recipe of finitely many additions, multiplications, divisions and root extractions applied to the coefficients. Writing that recipe down as a sequence of fields — start with Q\mathbb{Q}, throw in one new radical at a time — turns a vague hope ("is there a formula?") into a precise mathematical object one can actually study.

Q=K0⊂K1⊂⋯⊂Kr,Ki=Ki−1(aini)\mathbb{Q} = K_0 \subset K_1 \subset \cdots \subset K_r, \quad K_i = K_{i-1}(\sqrt[n_i]{a_i})
Detailed analysis

Saying that a root of ff is 'expressible by radicals' means there is a finite tower of fields Q=K0⊂K1⊂⋯⊂Kr\mathbb{Q} = K_0 \subset K_1 \subset \cdots \subset K_r with Ki=Ki−1(aini)K_i = K_{i-1}(\sqrt[n_i]{a_i}) for some ai∈Ki−1a_i \in K_{i-1} and exponent ni≥2n_i \ge 2, such that the root lies in KrK_r. Inside the tower the four field operations are applied freely — they never enlarge a field — so the only genuinely new elements ever created are the nin_i-th roots. The classical formulas are exactly such towers read off in reverse: the quadratic formula uses a single layer Q(b2−4ac)\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{b^2-4ac}), while Cardano's cubic formula needs one layer adjoining a cube root of unity and another adjoining −q/2+D3\sqrt[3]{-q/2+\sqrt{D}}.

The containment formulation matters: one does not ask that KrK_r equal the splitting field EE of ff, only that E⊆KrE \subseteq K_r. That makes 'solvable by radicals' a property of field embeddings, and it converts the permutation-theoretic question Ruffini and Abel originally asked into pure field theory: does any radical tower at all have a top containing EE?

Two subtleties already visible in the definition will matter later. First, the radicand aia_i ranges over all of Ki−1K_{i-1}, not merely over Q\mathbb{Q}, so nesting is essential — that is what 'a formula with radicals inside radicals' means formally. Second, in general Ki/Ki−1K_i/K_{i-1} is neither normal nor Galois, so the raw tower is not yet ready for group theory; Step 1 refines it.

Terms in this step
Field
A set of numbers, such as Q\mathbb{Q} or R\mathbb{R}, closed under addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division by anything nonzero.
Field extension
A field LL containing a smaller field KK, written L/KL/K; new elements are built from KK by adjoining extra numbers such as roots.
Radical extension
A one-step field extension Ki−1(an)K_{i-1}(\sqrt[n]{a}) formed by adjoining an nn-th root of some element aa already present in Ki−1K_{i-1}.
Knowledge used in this step