MathLabs

Worked solution: Abel–Ruffini theorem and the Galois solvability criterion (1824)

Step 7 of 8: A5A_5 is simple and non-abelian, so S5S_5 is not solvable
In plain words

Trying to break S5S_5 apart into a stack of simple, commutative gearboxes hits a wall almost immediately: the only nontrivial subgroup one can peel off is the group of even permutations A5A_5, and A5A_5 itself is a solid, seamless block with no further way to break it apart — it has no smaller normal pieces at all, and it is stubbornly non-commutative. One unbreakable, non-commutative block anywhere in the stack is enough to disqualify the whole group from being solvable.

1◃A5◃S5 is the only composition series,A5 simple, non-abelian,  ∣A5∣=601 \triangleleft A_5 \triangleleft S_5 \text{ is the only composition series}, \quad A_5 \text{ simple, non-abelian}, \; |A_5| = 60
Detailed analysis

For the criterion in Step 5 to make the generic quintic unsolvable by radicals, S5S_5 itself must fail to be a solvable group. For n≥5n\ge5, the symmetric group SnS_n has exactly one nontrivial proper normal subgroup, the alternating group AnA_n (the even permutations), so 1◃An◃Sn1\triangleleft A_n\triangleleft S_n is the only possible composition series. For n≥5n\ge5, AnA_n is simple — it has no normal subgroups at all besides itself and {1}\{1\} — and it is not abelian (for instance in A5A_5, two different 33-cycles typically fail to commute). A simple non-abelian group can never be replaced in a subnormal chain by anything smaller, so the chain 1◃A5◃S51\triangleleft A_5\triangleleft S_5 cannot be refined into one with only abelian quotients: the quotient A5/1≅A5A_5/1\cong A_5 is itself non-abelian. Hence S5S_5 is not a solvable group.

Terms in this step
Alternating group
The group AnA_n of even permutations of nn objects (those built from an even number of swaps); it has index 22 in SnS_n.
Simple group
A group with no normal subgroups other than the trivial group and itself — it cannot be broken into smaller normal pieces.
Knowledge used in this step