Worked solution: Potential automorphy of symmetric powers proves the Sato–Tate conjecture (2011)
For an elliptic curve over the rational numbers, reducing modulo a prime and counting points gives a number close to ; the error term is, by a 1930s theorem of Hasse, always small enough that can be written as for some angle .
Sato and Tate independently guessed around 1960 that, as ranges over primes, these angles do not spread out evenly like a uniform dartboard, but cluster according to a specific -shaped density — the same distribution that shows up for eigenvalues of random rotation matrices.
For an elliptic curve and a prime of good reduction, Hasse's theorem (1933) gives for the trace of Frobenius , so there is a unique angle with — the eigenvalues of Frobenius on are . The hypothesis 'non-CM' matters: for curves with complex multiplication the distribution is provably different (a mixture of a uniform part and a discrete part), so the conjecture is stated precisely for non-CM .
Around 1960 Mikio Sato (numerically) and John Tate (theoretically, via algebraic cycles) conjectured that the are equidistributed for the measure on . This is the pushforward of Haar measure on to conjugacy classes — the 'random matrix' signature indicating that the Frobenius conjugacy classes in the -adic representation behave like a maximally random family in a compact unitary group.
The statement is statistical: it concerns the distribution of infinitely many individual numbers , not any single one. The entire difficulty is to convert this counting statement into an analytic one about functions — a conversion executed by Serre's criterion in the next step.
- non-CM elliptic curve
- An elliptic curve whose only endomorphisms are multiplication by integers, i.e. without complex multiplication (CM); most elliptic curves are of this type, and the Sato–Tate conjecture is specifically about them.
- equidistribution
- A sequence of numbers equidistributes with respect to a measure if, for every interval, the fraction of the sequence landing in it converges to of that interval, so the sequence 'fills up' the space according to rather than randomly.