MathLabs

Worked solution: Viazovska's modular form solution to sphere packing in dimensions 8 and 24

Step 3 of 9: Why equality forces ff and f^\hat f to vanish exactly on E8E_8
In plain words

Poisson summation is a magic trick that turns a sum of ff over a lattice's points into a sum of f^\hat f over a related lattice; applying it to the ball centres of the E8E_8 packing pins the Cohn–Elkies ratio f(0)/f^(0)f(0)/\hat f(0) from below by a specific number, 24=162^4=16, the reciprocal covolume of the scaled E8E_8 lattice. So to prove E8E_8 is optimal it is enough — and, tightly, necessary — to build a test function achieving equality in that identity, which forces ff to be zero everywhere the lattice's balls touch and f^\hat f to be zero on the corresponding dual pattern.

∑ℓ∈12Λ8f(ℓ)=24∑ℓ∈2Λ8f^(ℓ)  ⟹  f(0)f^(0)≥24\sum_{\ell\in\frac{1}{\sqrt2}\Lambda_8} f(\ell) = 2^4 \sum_{\ell\in\sqrt2\Lambda_8} \hat f(\ell) \;\Longrightarrow\; \frac{f(0)}{\hat f(0)} \ge 2^4
Detailed analysis

The Poisson summation formula relates sums of a function over a lattice to sums of its Fourier transform over the dual lattice; for the E8E_8-lattice packing 12Λ8\tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}\Lambda_8 this gives ∑ℓ∈12Λ8f(ℓ)=24∑ℓ∈2Λ8f^(ℓ)\sum_{\ell\in\frac{1}{\sqrt2}\Lambda_8} f(\ell) = 2^4 \sum_{\ell\in\sqrt2\Lambda_8} \hat f(\ell). Combined with the sign conditions f≤0f\le 0 outside the ball and f^≥0\hat f \ge 0 everywhere, the left side is at most f(0)f(0) (only the origin term can be positive) and the right side is at least 24f^(0)2^4 \hat f(0) (only the origin term is guaranteed, and every other term is ≥0\ge 0), which forces f(0)/f^(0)≥24f(0)/\hat f(0) \ge 2^4, exactly reproducing the Cohn–Elkies bound for the E8E_8 density.

Equality throughout this chain — the only way to actually prove E8E_8 is optimal rather than merely bound it — requires f(ℓ)=0f(\ell)=0 for every nonzero ℓ∈12Λ8\ell \in \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}\Lambda_8 (every other packing vector) and f^(ℓ)=0\hat f(\ell) = 0 for every nonzero ℓ∈2Λ8\ell \in \sqrt2\Lambda_8. Since E8E_8 vectors come in shells of length 2n\sqrt{2n}, this means ff and f^\hat f must each vanish, to a very specific double-zero order, at every one of these shell radii; constructing such a pair is exactly the analytic problem solved in the next two steps.

Terms in this step
Poisson summation formula
An identity that rewrites the sum of a function over every point of a lattice as the sum of its Fourier transform over every point of the dual lattice, letting a sign condition on f^\hat f control a sum that would otherwise be hard to bound directly.
Knowledge used in this step