MathLabs

Worked solution: Wantzel's algebraic impossibility proof via field extensions (1837)

Step 4 of 7: Turning 'trisect 60∘60^\circ' into a cubic equation
In plain words

There is a shortcut connecting an angle to three times that angle: the triple-angle formula for cosine. Setting θ=20∘\theta=20^\circ, so that 3θ=60∘3\theta=60^\circ is a nice, familiar angle, turns the geometric question 'can we construct 20∘20^\circ?' into a purely algebraic one: 'is this specific number a root of this specific cubic equation?'

This is the bridge Wantzel needed: geometry on one side of the equals sign, an equation with whole-number coefficients on the other.

4cos⁡3(20∘)−3cos⁡(20∘)=12  →x=2cos⁡20∘  x3−3x−1=04\cos^3(20^\circ) - 3\cos(20^\circ) = \tfrac12 \;\xrightarrow{x=2\cos20^\circ}\; x^3 - 3x - 1 = 0
Detailed analysis

An angle θ\theta is constructible exactly when the length cos⁡θ\cos\theta is constructible, since dropping a perpendicular from a point on the unit circle at angle θ\theta onto the xx-axis produces the segment cos⁡θ\cos\theta, and conversely θ\theta is recovered from cos⁡θ\cos\theta by erecting a perpendicular. Take θ=20∘\theta = 20^\circ, so trisecting 60∘60^\circ is possible exactly when 20∘20^\circ, equivalently cos⁡20∘\cos 20^\circ, is constructible.

The triple-angle identity cos⁡3θ=4cos⁡3θ−3cos⁡θ\cos 3\theta = 4\cos^3\theta - 3\cos\theta applied at θ=20∘\theta=20^\circ gives 4cos⁡3(20∘)−3cos⁡(20∘)=cos⁡(60∘)=124\cos^3(20^\circ) - 3\cos(20^\circ) = \cos(60^\circ) = \tfrac12. Multiplying through by 22 and substituting x=2cos⁡(20∘)x = 2\cos(20^\circ) (so cos⁡20∘=x/2\cos 20^\circ = x/2) turns this into 8(x/2)3−6(x/2)=18(x/2)^3 - 6(x/2) = 1, i.e. x3−3x−1=0x^3 - 3x - 1 = 0. Since multiplying or dividing by the nonzero rational number 22 does not change constructibility, cos⁡20∘\cos 20^\circ is constructible if and only if x=2cos⁡20∘x = 2\cos 20^\circ is.

So the entire geometric problem has been reduced to a single algebraic question about the integer-coefficient cubic P(x)=x3−3x−1P(x) = x^3 - 3x - 1: is its root x=2cos⁡20∘x = 2\cos 20^\circ constructible? The next step answers this by computing the degree of PP over Q\mathbb{Q}.

Terms in this step
Triple-angle formula
The trigonometric identity cos⁡3θ=4cos⁡3θ−3cos⁡θ\cos 3\theta = 4\cos^3\theta - 3\cos\theta, expressing the cosine of three times an angle in terms of the cosine of the angle itself.
Knowledge used in this step