Worked solution: Wantzel's algebraic impossibility proof via field extensions (1837)
There is a shortcut connecting an angle to three times that angle: the triple-angle formula for cosine. Setting , so that is a nice, familiar angle, turns the geometric question 'can we construct ?' into a purely algebraic one: 'is this specific number a root of this specific cubic equation?'
This is the bridge Wantzel needed: geometry on one side of the equals sign, an equation with whole-number coefficients on the other.
An angle is constructible exactly when the length is constructible, since dropping a perpendicular from a point on the unit circle at angle onto the -axis produces the segment , and conversely is recovered from by erecting a perpendicular. Take , so trisecting is possible exactly when , equivalently , is constructible.
The triple-angle identity applied at gives . Multiplying through by and substituting (so ) turns this into , i.e. . Since multiplying or dividing by the nonzero rational number does not change constructibility, is constructible if and only if is.
So the entire geometric problem has been reduced to a single algebraic question about the integer-coefficient cubic : is its root constructible? The next step answers this by computing the degree of over .
- Triple-angle formula
- The trigonometric identity , expressing the cosine of three times an angle in terms of the cosine of the angle itself.