Worked solution: Gelfond–Schneider transcendence proof via auxiliary functions (1934)
An algebraic number is one that solves some polynomial equation with whole-number coefficients, like (root of ); a transcendental number, like or , solves no such equation. When David Hilbert listed his 23 problems in 1900, the seventh asked about numbers like : you take an algebraic base (here ) that is neither nor , raise it to an algebraic but irrational power (here ), and ask whether the result must be transcendental.
Hilbert believed this was fantastically hard — he expected it to be solved only after the Riemann Hypothesis — yet Aleksandr Gelfond and Theodor Schneider each found a complete proof in 1934, independently, using a clever construction now called an auxiliary function.
In his 1900 address Mathematische Probleme Hilbert asked, as the seventh of twenty-three problems, whether must be transcendental whenever is algebraic with and is algebraic irrational; here means any fixed value of for a chosen branch of the logarithm, since different branches differ by powers of , which the theorem itself shows are transcendental. Hilbert cited and as test cases and predicted the problem would outlast the Riemann Hypothesis.
Partial progress came quickly: Kuzmin (1930) handled real quadratic by a continued-fraction refinement of Gelfond's 1929 method, which had already proved transcendental. The general case fell in 1934 to Gelfond and, independently, Schneider; Schneider's variant was later recast by Siegel into the form used here, where one works with two entire functions rather than Gelfond's original single determinant-built function. The source cited in the file metadata is Gelfond's 1934 paper Sur le septième problème de Hilbert.
The argument is a quantified proof by contradiction, now the template for all of transcendence theory. Assume is algebraic and form the number field . One constructs a nonzero entire function , built from and , that vanishes to high order at the points where its values lie in . A first nonzero derivative is then a nonzero element of that complex analysis (Jensen's formula) bounds above by while algebraic number theory (the product formula over conjugates) bounds below by ; since outruns , the two bounds collide, forcing to be transcendental.
- Algebraic and transcendental numbers
- A complex number is algebraic if it is a root of some nonzero polynomial with integer (equivalently, rational) coefficients; otherwise it is transcendental. Every rational number and every root like is algebraic; and are known to be transcendental.