MathLabs

Worked solution: Dehn's invariant: the tetrahedron and cube are not scissors-congruent (1900)

Step 2 of 7: Define the Dehn invariant from edge lengths and dihedral angles
In plain words

Every edge of a polyhedron has two numbers attached to it: how long it is, and how sharply the two faces meeting there fold (the dihedral angle). Dehn's idea is to multiply each edge's length by a coded version of its angle and add everything up — but the coding is designed so that any angle which is a 'round' fraction of a straight line (like a right angle) contributes exactly zero, no matter how long the edge is.

Dehn⁡(P)=∑eℓ(e)⊗[θ(e)] ∈ R⊗Q(R/πQ)\operatorname{Dehn}(P) = \sum_{e} \ell(e) \otimes [\theta(e)] \ \in \ \mathbb{R} \otimes_{\mathbb{Q}} (\mathbb{R}/\pi\mathbb{Q})
Detailed analysis

For a polyhedron PP, let ℓ(e)\ell(e) and θ(e)\theta(e) denote the length and dihedral angle of each edge ee. Dehn defines Dehn⁡(P)=∑eℓ(e)⊗[θ(e)]\operatorname{Dehn}(P) = \sum_e \ell(e) \otimes [\theta(e)], an element of the tensor product R⊗Q(R/πQ)\mathbb{R} \otimes_{\mathbb{Q}} (\mathbb{R}/\pi\mathbb{Q}) (lengths paired Q\mathbb{Q}-bilinearly with angles taken modulo rational multiples of π\pi). Working modulo πQ\pi\mathbb{Q} is essential: it is what lets a rational multiple of π\pi contribute nothing, matching the fact that angles summing to a straight or full angle should not obstruct a dissection.

The tensor product ⊗Q\otimes_{\mathbb{Q}} is what makes this a genuine, checkable invariant rather than an unwieldy pair of numbers: it declares ℓ⊗[θ1+θ2]=ℓ⊗[θ1]+ℓ⊗[θ2]\ell \otimes [\theta_1 + \theta_2] = \ell \otimes [\theta_1] + \ell \otimes [\theta_2] and (qℓ)⊗[θ]=ℓ⊗[qθ](q\ell) \otimes [\theta] = \ell \otimes [q\theta] for rational qq, so that lengths interact with angles exactly like a bilinear pairing, and two elements of R⊗Q(R/πQ)\mathbb{R} \otimes_{\mathbb{Q}} (\mathbb{R}/\pi\mathbb{Q}) can be compared for equality using ordinary linear algebra over Q\mathbb{Q}.

The next step shows why this particular combination of length and angle, added over all edges, deserves to be called an invariant at all: it must not change when a polyhedron is cut into pieces and reassembled.

Terms in this step
dihedral angle
The angle between the two faces of a polyhedron that meet along a given edge, measured inside the solid; a cube's dihedral angles are all π/2\pi/2, a regular tetrahedron's are all arccos⁡(1/3)\arccos(1/3).
tensor product ⊗Q\otimes_{\mathbb{Q}}
An algebraic construction that combines two objects (here, real lengths and angles modulo πQ\pi\mathbb{Q}) into a single new object, forcing the combination to behave bilinearly with respect to rational scalars, which is exactly the structure needed to compare Dehn invariants by ordinary algebra.
Knowledge used in this step