Worked solution: Wantzel's algebraic impossibility proof for doubling the cube (1837)
Legend says the citizens of Delos, hit by a plague, consulted an oracle that told them to double the volume of their cubical altar. They doubled every edge, getting eight times the volume by mistake — the real answer requires multiplying each edge by , not by .
So the task is precise: given a cube of side (volume ), use only straightedge and compass to build a segment of length such that a cube on that segment has volume exactly . Wantzel's 1837 paper shows this specific segment can never be built.
The classical 'doubling the cube' (or Delian) problem asks for a straightedge-and-compass construction, starting from a unit segment, of the edge of a cube whose volume is twice that of a unit cube: , so , a root of . The problem was already ancient by the time of Hippocrates of Chios (5th century BCE), who reduced it to finding two mean proportionals between and , and it resisted straightedge-and-compass solution for over two thousand years.
Wantzel's 1837 paper resolves it by the same method used for angle trisection: translate constructibility into an algebraic degree condition, then check whether satisfies it. The remaining steps carry this out: first the general criterion that constructible numbers have degree a power of over , then the fact that is irreducible over , giving — not a power of .
Unlike the trisection problem, here there is only one relevant number to test, itself, which makes this the more compact of Wantzel's two classical impossibility proofs.
- Mean proportionals
- Numbers inserted between and so that ; Hippocrates showed doubling the cube is equivalent to finding two mean proportionals between and .